2026 Anthem Awards Winners Announced!

The Hidden Cost of AI Pricing

Consumer Reports PROJECT
The Hidden Cost of AI Pricing by Consumer Reports

credits

Title
  • The Hidden Cost of AI Pricing
Entrant
  • Consumer Reports

About This Project

Summary

Most people have no way of knowing when AI influences the prices they pay. Consumer Reports, with Groundwork Collaborative and More Perfect Union, uncovered that Instacart was testing AI technology that showed different shoppers prices that varied up to 23% for the same grocery items. About three-quarters of the products we checked offered different prices. The campaign exposed hidden algorithmic pricing practices and sparked a national dialogue on AI transparency, fairness, and accountability.

Goals & Objectives

To reveal hidden AI pricing practices, empower consumers to understand how algorithms can affect everyday costs, and push companies toward greater transparency and accountability in AI-driven decision-making.

Results & Impact

Following the investigation, Instacart ended its AI pricing experiments, and Wegmans stopped using the pricing software. 42K people joined CR's call to action. The campaign helped spur proposed federal legislation, congressional and FTC scrutiny, state probes, and new laws on algorithmic pricing.

the team

Derek Kravitz
  • Deputy, Special Projects
  • Consumer Reports
Angel Han
  • Campaign Manager
  • Consumer Reports
Alan Smith
  • Associate Director, Community Leadership & Research
  • Consumer Reports
Cyrus Rassool
  • Director, Public Affairs & Strategic Communications
  • Consumer Reports
Lindsay Owens
  • President and CEO
  • Groundwork Collaborative
Katie Wells
  • Director of Research
  • Groundwork Collaborative
Eric Gardner
  • Business Reporter
  • More Perfect Union