The Judges' Table Part I with Heather Elliott and Nicholas Sugai
Watch now on Youtube or Listen on Spotify or Apple Podcasts
What separates good work from great work?
What makes an idea actually stick? Is it the creativity behind it, the way it reaches an audience, or the difference it makes once it gets there? For the first part of The Judges’ Table series, host Patricia McLoughlin sits down with two members of the International Academy of Digital Arts and Sciences, Heather Elliott, Chief Development and Marketing Officer at National 4-H Council, and Nick Sugai, SVP of Campaigns and Programs at the Ad Council, to talk about what stood out to them while judging the 6th Annual Anthem Awards.
From campaigns that made serious issues more approachable to surprisingly simple ideas that led to measurable change, Heather and Nick share some of their favorite work from this year’s competition and what made those projects stand out. They get into Gift of Life’s Hero Gum, which turned stem cell donation into an unexpectedly accessible call to action, and LEGO’s MRI play sets, which helped make a stressful experience less intimidating for young patients. They also discuss AARP’s Dr. Adam and a 988 campaign that found a way to reach construction workers where they were.
But the conversation goes beyond the winning campaigns. Heather and Nick talk about what it really takes to get good work off the ground: understanding your audience, getting stakeholders on board, knowing when to take a creative risk, and being willing to change course when something isn’t working. They also share their perspectives on AI’s role in social impact storytelling, why authenticity and lived experience matter, and how smaller organizations can make meaningful work happen without massive budgets.
Whether you’re thinking about your next campaign, trying to make the most of limited resources, or figuring out what impact should actually look like in 2027, this conversation offers a lot to take away.
In this episode:
- What makes a campaign stand out, and what separates a good idea from one that actually drives change
- Why understanding your audience should shape everything, from the creative concept to where and how you show up
- The difference between measuring activity and measuring real outcomes
- Where AI can help social impact organizations, and where the human touch is still essential
- How humor, simplicity, and a little creativity can help make serious issues more approachable
- What happens behind the scenes to bring ambitious ideas to life, from stakeholder buy-in to making room for risk
- Why transparency matters when a campaign doesn’t go according to plan
- How smaller organizations can make an impact by focusing on their audience and leveraging lived experiences
- What Heather and Nick hope to see more of in 2027, from creator partnerships to more authentic storytelling

